Differential analysis of microbial interaction networks

Microbiome studies increasingly indicate that disease-associated shifts cannot be understood from compositional changes alone. The functional architecture of microbial communities-encoded in patterns of association among microbial gene families-may reveal how these systems reorganize across biological conditions. Here, we present a network-based framework for characterizing microbiome rewiring across conditions. The approach combines condition-specific network inference, differential network analysis, and pathway-level network analysis to identify associations that are gained, lost, or altered between groups, with a specific focus on sex-dependent differences. We apply the framework to inflammatory bowel disease, type 2 diabetes, and atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ACVD), comparing male and female-specific microbial gene family networks within each disease context. Across these settings, differential networks flag large numbers of candidate rewired associations; however, permutation testing (sex labels shuffled, group sizes preserved, 500 permutations for gene-family networks, and 1000 for pathway networks) shows that the global amount of apparent rewiring is not greater than expected under the null at the global or edge level in any cohort, and that most edges exclusive to one group are induced by group-specific feature filtering rather than by a genuine change in association ($\sim $80%-83% in ACVD). We therefore present the method as a rigorously validated framework and a cautionary case study: the differential-network machinery is sound, but the headline biological signal in a naive analysis is largely a property of correlation thresholding and, for the longitudinal inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) cohort, of pseudoreplication. The only non-null result across all validations is a SOHPIE-DNA per-taxon test in the IBD disease arm (15 taxa at FDR $< 0.05$), which we report as a single nominal finding requiring independent replication. Code, data, and supplementary information are available at https://github.com/mmilano87/NetMicrobiome.