Comparison of Caplan's irreversible thermodynamic theory of muscle contraction with chemical data

Recently Caplan (1) applied the concepts of irreversible thermodynamics and cybernetics to contracting muscle and derived Hill's force-velocity relation. Wilkie and Woledge (2) then compared Caplan's theory to chemical rates inferred from heat data and concluded that the theory was not consistent with the data. Caplan defended his theory in later papers (3, 4) but without any direct experimental verifications. As Wilkie and Woledge (2) point out, the rate of phosphorylcreatine (PC) breakdown during steady states of shortening has not been observed because of technical difficulties. In this paper it is shown that the rate equations may be directly integrated with time to obtain relations among actual quantities instead of rates. The validity of this integration is based on experimental evidence which indicates that certain combinations of the transport coefficients are constant with muscle length. These equations are then directly compared to experimental data of Cain, Infante, and Davies (5) with the following conclusions: (a) The measured variations of DeltaPC for isotonic contractions are almost exactly as predicted by Caplan's theory. (b) The value of the chemical rate ratio, nu(m)/nu(o), obtained from these data was 3.53 which is close to the value of 3 suggested by Caplan (3). (c) The maximum value of the chemical affinity for PC splitting was found to be 10.6 k cal/mole which is as expected from in vitro measurements (2). Because of the excellent agreement between theory and experiment, we conclude that Caplan's theory definitely warrants further investigation.