[Reversibility of airway obstruction in asthma and chronic bronchitis (author transl)]

Our purpose was to determine whether, in patients with airway obstruction, the change in the forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) which occurs after a bronchodilator drug, is helpful in differentiating asthma from chronic bronchitis. Two groups of patients (48 with asthma and 42 with chronic bronchitis) having a comparable level of initial airway obstruction were selected according to clinical criteria. After salbutamol (200 microgram inhaled) the number of subjects showing a change in FEV1 of at least 20 percent of its initial value or 10 percent of its predicted value was significantly greater (p less than 0.01) in the asthmatic than in the bronchitic group. Lesser changes in FEV1 did not significantly separate the two groups. When the changes in FEV1 were expressed as percentages of both initial and predicted values, the number of positive responses increased in the asthmatic group. However, there were still 20 asthmatics with little or no change in FEV1 after salbutamol who could not be distinguished from the patients with chronic bronchitis. From these data we conclude that, in patients with airway obstruction, a large bronchodilator-induced change in FEV1 strongly suggests the diagnosis of asthma but that the presence of "irreversible" airway obstruction does not disprove it.