Related Experiment Videos
Initiating day care at three years of age: effects on attachment
Insights
Daycare experience in toddlers did not impair mother attachment. While daycare children showed less distress, effects varied by sex, with males exhibiting more exploration and home-care males seeking more maternal proximity.
Area of Science:
- Developmental Psychology
- Child Development
- Attachment Theory
Background:
- Attachment security is crucial for child development.
- The impact of non-parental care, such as daycare, on attachment is a significant area of research.
- Previous studies have yielded mixed results regarding the effects of early daycare exposure.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the attachment security of 42-month-old children with daycare experience compared to those without.
- To examine potential sex-based differences in the effects of daycare on child behavior and attachment.
- To determine if daycare experience negatively impacts the mother-child attachment bond.
Main Methods:
- Utilized the Ainsworth-Wittig Strange Situation procedure to assess attachment.
- Compared 12 toddlers with 6 months of daycare experience to individually matched home-reared controls.
- Analyzed behavioral differences, including distress, exploration, and interaction with the mother and a stranger, stratified by sex.
Main Results:
- Daycare children exhibited less distress in later stages of the Strange Situation compared to home-care children.
- No significant group differences were observed in most behaviors, including those directed towards the mother.
- Daycare had differential effects based on sex; male subgroups showed larger score variations than female subgroups.
- Daycare males displayed increased exploratory manipulation; home-care males showed more maternal proximity-seeking and complex stranger interactions.
Conclusions:
- Daycare experience does not appear to impair the quality of attachment to the mother in toddlers.
- Sex is a moderating factor in the behavioral outcomes associated with early daycare exposure.
- Findings suggest that quality of care, rather than mere presence in daycare, may be a more critical determinant of attachment.
Abstract:
Using the Ainsworth-Wittig strange situation, 12 42-month-old children with approximately 6-months of day-care experience were compared with individually matched children who had not had group child-rearing experience; 8 members of each experience group were female, and 4 members were male. While the day-care children showed less distress than the home-care children in the latter parts of the laboratory situation, the 2 groups were not different with respect to most other behaviors, including those toward the mother. However, day-care experience appeared to have differential effects as a function of sex; large differences were often found between the scores of the male subgroups, whereas the differences between the female subgroups were usually small. The day-care males exhibited the most exploratory manipulation, and the home-care males showed the most approach and proximity seeking toward the mother and the strongest approach toward and avoidance of the stranger. These results did not support the idea that day-care experience impair attachment to the mother.