Carcinoma of the esophagus: twelve years' experience with a philosophy for palliation

Twelve years of experience have now been gained with a new therapeutic approach to carcinoma of the esophagus. In this approach, the primary goal of treatment is palliation, with cure an important but secondary objective. Carcinomas in the upper third of the esophagus are treated by radiation therapy unless there is severe obstruction or tracheal invasion, in which case colon interposition is performed. Limited resection with esophagogastrostomy is performed through a right thoracotomy and midline laparotomy for neoplasms in the middle third of the esophagus and through a left thoracotomy for carcinomas in the lower third. Since 1969, 161 patients have been evaluated, of whom 107 (66%) have been managed according to the new protocol. Twenty patients with carcinomas of the upper third of the esophagus were treated primarily by radiotherapy and 7 by colon interposition. Resection was performed in 78 of the 80 patients with carcinomas of the middle and lower thirds. There were 9 operative deaths (10%). Palliation, of superior quality to that obtained by previous methods, was provided to 95 of the 107 patients. Survival also is at least on a par with that obtained before.