The short-term bronchodilator effects of fenoterol and ipratropium in asthma

We studied the bronchodilator effects of inhaled fenoterol, a relatively selective beta-2 adrenergic agent, and ipratropium an anticholinergic drug, singly and in combination in 10 patients with asthma. The period of observation was 6 hr after aerosol administration. The six drug regimens used were fenoterol 100 micrograms, fenoterol 200 micrograms fenoterol 50 micrograms combined with 20 micrograms of ipratropium, fenoterol 100 micrograms combined with 40 micrograms of ipratropium, 40 micrograms of ipratropium, and placebo. Measurements consisted of spirometry with determination of forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), maximal expiratory flow at 50% of vital capacity (V50), specific airway conductance, lung volumes, and heart rate. Bronchodilation with regimens containing fenoterol was rapid, with 75% of the maximum response achieved by 5 min, while the peak effect of ipratropium was delayed for 1 to 2 hr. Fenoterol 100 micrograms produced approximately half the degree of improvement in FEV1 and V50 compared with 200 micrograms of fenoterol. The addition of 40 micrograms of ipratropium to 100 micrograms of fenoterol resulted in bronchodilation equivalent to 200 micrograms fenoterol and was associated with a more prolonged effect than fenoterol 100 micrograms. Tremor was observed in two-subjects inhaling fenoterol 200 micrograms but was not observed with any other regimen. It is concluded that the combination of inhaled ipratropium and fenoterol is an effective bronchodilator in asthma, achieving efficacy similar to that of fenoterol alone but with fewer side effects.