Information about three-dimensional shape and direction of illumination in a square-wave grating

A homogeneous grey picture and a 'Mondrian' type of picture were illuminated by a projector with square-wave gratings of thirty different contrast values used as slides. Ten observers reported whether the picture appeared three-dimensional (3-D) (pleated) or flat. 3-D responses in this situation indicate colour constancy 'at the cost of' nonveridical depth perception. The frequencies of 3-D responses were significantly higher for the structured picture than for the homogeneous grey one. In reports of the direction from which the apparent 3-D object appeared to be illuminated there was a significant preference for responses "from above" when the grating was horizontally oriented. With vertical orientation there was no preference for "from the left" or "from the right". The results from the first experiment contradict traditional cue theories of depth perception since the projection of the borders between the fields of the structured picture was invariant and expected to inform about the flatness of the picture. They are, however, in line with a model for perceptual analysis of reflected light into common and relative components proposed earlier by Bergström. The difference in perceived direction of illumination between horizontally and vertically orientated gratings is discussed in connection with human ecology.