Comparison of 6-min "all-out" and incremental exercise tests in elite oarsmen

A high aerobic capacity is an important criterion for rowing success. Two exercise protocols, the 6-min "all-out" (6M-AO) and progressive incremental (PI) tests, have been used to evaluate physiological performance in rowers and to select team members. We measured heart rate (HR), minute ventilation (VE), oxygen consumption (VO2), and carbon dioxide production (VCO2) every 30 s, and obtained ratings of perceived exertion (RPE) from 12 candidates for the 1983 United States Men's Lightweight Rowing Team. Testing was randomized and each oarsman performed a different test on the rowing ergometer on consecutive days. For the group, age was 23 +/- 2 yr (mean +/- SD), height was 183 +/- 3 cm, and weight was 72.2 +/- 1.4 kg. Peak physiological values were achieved in the first 2 min of exercise for the 6M-AO test, but in the last 2 min for the PI test. There were no statistically significant differences among peak values for HR, VE, VO2, VCO2, and RPE with each test. The peak ventilatory equivalent for oxygen (VE/VO2) was also similar. The onset of anaerobic metabolism was observed at 83 +/- 4% of peak VO2 during the PI test, while anaerobic metabolism has been shown to occur within the first minute of the 6M-AO test. We conclude that physiological values at peak exercise were similar for the 6M-AO and PI tests. Because the onset of anaerobic metabolism can only be determined by noninvasive means using the PI test, this method of testing is preferable for the physiological assessment of rowing performance.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)