A critical method of evaluating tests for male infertility

Considerable uncertainty surrounds the selection of test values that separate infertile from fertile men in the evaluation of male infertility. We herein describe an objective method of determining these values, referred to as threshold values, for different infertility tests. Using test results from fertile men threshold values were chosen such that 96 per cent of the semen samples from the fertile men were scored as fertile. These threshold values then were used to evaluate 100 semen samples from 74 men presenting for evaluation of infertility. Using this method we constructed infertility profiles on each of the 100 semen samples presented for infertility evaluation and found that the zona pellucida-free hamster egg penetration test (a measure of a spermatozoon's ability to undergo capacitation and penetrate an egg) identified 66 per cent of these samples as infertile, while multiple exposure photomicrography (a quantitative measure of sperm motility) identified 54 per cent of these samples as infertile. This compares with results from routine semen analyses using the same method, which identified none of the samples as infertile by sperm motility grade, 1 per cent by semen pH, 4 per cent by the percentage of motile sperm, 7 per cent by the total count of motile sperm, 10 per cent by the total sperm count, 11 per cent by the semen leukocyte concentration, 12 per cent by the concentration of motile sperm, 13 per cent by ejaculate volume, 16 per cent by sperm concentration and 27 per cent by sperm morphology. This method of analyzing infertility test results provides insight into the potential causes of male infertility and offers a critical approach towards understanding the complex problem of male fertility dysfunction.