Comparison between an alpha-adrenergic antagonist and a beta 2-adrenergic agonist in bronchial asthma

Fifteen patients suffering from asthma received inhalations of phentolamine, albuterol (salbutamol), a combination of phentolamine and albuterol, and placebo, in a single-blind fashion; the changes in the pulmonary function tests were recorded over a three-hour period. Three patients responded to phentolamine with marked bronchodilatation, whereas severe bronchoconstriction was induced by the drug in two patients. Five patients improved more with phentolamine than with placebo, while all patients improved more markedly with albuterol and still more following inhalation of the combination of both drugs. As a group, there were no statistically significant differences between the responses to phentolamine compared with placebo, or between albuterol alone compared with the combination of both drugs. We concluded that both alpha-antagonist and beta 2-agonist agents act in the same direction in most patients, the beta 2-agonist being the dominant. These results do not offer convincing proof that enhanced alpha-adrenergic activity is the main bronchoconstrictor mechanism even in those few with good response to phentolamine, who also showed very good responsiveness to albuterol. The mechanism of phentolamine-induced bronchoconstriction was discussed, but in the light of presently accepted theories, we were unable to evolve a reasonable explanation.