Echocardiographic evaluation of porcine bioprosthetic valves: experience with 309 normal and 59 dysfunctioning valves

To determine the clinical value of echocardiographic evaluation of porcine bioprosthetic valves, the findings in all patients who had porcine bioprosthetic valve replacement and adequate quality echocardiographic studies from 1978 to 1982 were analyzed. The study includes 309 normal and 59 dysfunctioning valves. Valve dysfunction resulted from spontaneous cusp degeneration in 39 (34 valve regurgitations, 5 stenoses), infective endocarditis in 12, paravalvular regurgitation in 5, regurgitation of redundant cusps, mitral valve thrombi, and aortic stent stenosis in 3 others. Echocardiographic findings were correlated with gross surgical pathologic or autopsy findings in 45 of the 59 dysfunctioning valves. Echocardiographic abnormalities were demonstrated in 41 of 59 (69%) dysfunctioning valves. A systolic mitral or diastolic aortic valve flutter was diagnostic of a regurgitant valve caused by a torn or unsupported cusp margin and was observed in 28 of 34 (82%) regurgitant valves with no false-positive studies. Echocardiographic cusp thickness of greater than or equal to 3 mm correctly identified all regurgitant and stenotic valves with gross anatomic evidence of localized or generalized cusp thickening or calcific deposits. Echocardiographic valve abnormalities were observed in only 4 of 12 patients with infective endocarditis and in 1 of 5 with paravalvular regurgitation. Thus, echocardiography provides important information regarding the function of porcine bioprosthetic valves and is of value in the decision to replace these valves, especially when dysfunction is due to spontaneous cuspal degeneration. Echocardiography is neither sensitive nor specific in patients with infective endocarditis and paravalvular regurgitation.