Chromosomal analysis in vinyl chloride exposed workers: comparison of the standard technique with the sister-chromatid exchange technique

A group of 21 workers occupationally exposed to vinyl chloride and 6 controls were examined for the presence of chromosomal aberrations or sister-chromatid exchanges in their peripheral lymphocytes. These people comprised a second sampling from a group of exposed workers and controls first examined 18 months earlier. The vinyl chloride exposed workers showed levels of chromosomal aberrations elevated above those of the controls, but there was only a slight increase in sister-chromatid exchanges (per cell or per chromosome) and this increase was not statistically significant. Sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were also examined from in vitro cultures of lymphocytes exposed in G0/early G1 and late G1/early S phase to vinyl chloride, both with and without metabolic activation. There was no increase in SCEs in vitro without metabolic activation but there was a marked increase with metabolic activation and this increase was shown to be independent of cell-cycle phase. It thus was apparent that the small increases of SCEs in workers were not due to the inability of vinyl chloride to induce SCEs in human lymphocytes but were probably because of low exposures and SCE levels could have returned to normal relatively quickly after exposure. The present study suggested that the analysis of longer-living conventional chromosomal aberrations appeared to be a more sensitive monitor of exposure to vinyl chloride in exposed workers than the estimation of SCEs; however, it should be noted that in a 3rd sampling taken 24 months later the exposed workers had chromosomal aberration levels similar to the controls.