Metabolic insufficiency as a limiting factor in the dietetic treatment of obesity

Previous observations that acute total fasting decreases serum T3 and increase rT3 has prompted the following study. 17 obese women were placed on a 1000 kcal/day weight-reducing diet, and body weight (BW), serum T4, RT3U, T3, rT3, TSH and the Achilles tendon reflex (ATR) were estimated before and after each month for 3 consecutive months of the diet. The results showed a consistent decrease in serum T3, and inconsistent increase in rT3, a consistent prolongation of the ATR and a levelling-off of the BW loss after the second month of the diet. At 3 months there was a negative correlation between the decrease in BW and the increase in ATR, i.e. the more abnormal the ATR became, the less weight the patient lost. It is concluded: 1) Even a moderate hypocaloric diet in ambulatory patients induces a disturbance in the peripheral conversion of T4 to T3 and a secondary state of metabolic insufficiency. 2). This insufficiency is probable related to the observed tendency of the BW loss to level off after two months. 3) A controlled trial of physiologic doses of T3, such as 40 mu g/day, seems indicated, as opposed to pharmacologic dosed of T3 used by previous investigators.