[Prevalence of medullary sponge kidney in patients with and without nephrolithiasis]

Reports on the prevalence of medullary sponge kidneys have given conflicting results. The present work is aimed at defining the prevalence of this abnormality in renal stone formers compared with a non-stone-forming control population by strict radiological criteria. Three separate studies have been carried out: the retrospective analysis of 191 intravenous urographies, which had been performed in 1988; the respective prospective analysis of 104 consecutive intravenous urographies and of 149 consecutive urographies, which had been performed at the end of intravenous digitalized subtraction renal angiographies. The 444 patients were classified according to presence or absence of nephrolithiasis. After exclusion of 70 patients (16%) of which the X-ray didn't fulfill the quality criteria, urographies were classified as 'medullary sponge kidneys', 'papillary blush' or 'negative' according to the radiological aspect of the papillae. Diagnosis of medullary sponge kidneys was based on presence of at least three linear or round papillary opacities seen in at least on papilla even of one kidney on late films (at least ten minutes after injection of contrast medium), taken without ureteral obstruction or abdominal compression. Overall results reveal that prevalence of a medullary sponge kidney in renal stone formers (8.5%) is significantly (p < 0.01) higher than in the control population (1.5%) and higher than what has been generally reported. Results of the retrospective and of both prospective analysis did not significantly differ. The best diagnostic tool to unmask medullary sponge kidneys remains urography.