Trial-to-trial variability of corticospinal volleys in human subjects

The trial-to-trial variability of the different components of corticospinal volleys evoked by transcranial electrical stimulation of the motor cortex using a constant stimulus intensity was measured from epidural recordings during surgery to correct scoliosis. The recordings were made when there was no operative interference, and blood pressure, temperature, ventilation and anaesthetic regimen were stable. A simple D wave with a single negative peak of 10-30 microV amplitude was recorded in 4 patients. It varied little in amplitude (S.D.s < 8% for 100 consecutive single responses). In 4 patients the stimulus was adjusted to produce a complex D wave with 3 components, the earliest 2 of which arise from subcortical/brain-stem sites. The variability of amplitude of these components was high (S.D.s of 13-50%), but the variability of latency was low (S.D.s of 2-3%). Eighteen I waves were recorded in 6 of the subjects. Their variability from trial to trial was similar to that of the components of the complex D wave. It is argued that there would be greater trial-to-trial variability of the corticospinal volley in the awake state, particularly when the stimulus was magnetic rather than electrical. Explanations for changes in the compound muscle action potential produced by transcranial stimulation, electrical or magnetic, must take into account that a constant stimulus does not evoke an identical descending volley.