Correct preoperative localization: does it permit a change in operative strategy for primary hyperparathyroidism?

A meticulous bilateral neck exploration by an experienced endocrine surgeon offers a high cure rate with low morbidity for patients with primary hyperparathyroidism. The advent of localizing studies raises the possibility of unilateral neck exploration. The cost-effectiveness of preoperative localizing studies and unilateral neck exploration in primary hyperparathyroidism are controversial issues. This study was designed to determine the risks of missing a contralateral pathologic parathyroid gland in patients with preoperative localization that was confirmed at neck exploration.

Preoperative studies (ultrasonography, nuclear radioactive imaging scan, or both) were performed in 79 patients with primary hyperparathyroidism. In 58 patients a definite localization of an enlarged parathyroid gland was confirmed at operation. All patients underwent a meticulous bilateral neck exploration.

Unilateral neck exploration was feasible only in 73.4% of the patients, according to our localizing modalities, and an additional enlarged parathyroid gland on the contralateral side, not detected before operation, was revealed in five patients (8.6%). False-positive rates were 1.7% for ultrasonography and 13% for scan.

These results indicate an unacceptably high surgical failure rate for unilateral neck exploration guided by preoperative localizing studies compared with a bilateral neck exploration by an experienced endocrine surgeon, questioning the cost-effectiveness of preoperative localizing studies.