Value of prostate cancer screening in a comprehensive community cancer center

Early detection of prostate cancer may help decrease cancer deaths from this disease despite the increased incidence of prostate cancer. In 1990 and 1991 we conducted one-day "screens" for prostate cancer. This analysis was undertaken to determine the value of the screening procedures for detecting prostate cancer in the community. A total of 579 men, aged 39-84 years (mean 58 years), were evaluated by digital rectal examination (DRE) by a urologist, serum prostate specific antigen (PSA) determination by monoclonal antibody assay, and completion of a detailed questionnaire. Forty-eight percent had not seen a physician in over 2 years; 17% had a 1st- or 2nd-degree relative with prostate cancer. There was a 25% "suspicious" rate including 76 (13%) men with abnormal DRE only, 48 (8%) with abnormal PSA only, and 21 (4%) with abnormal DRE and PSA. Patients with findings suspicious for cancer were recontacted by telephone at 2-month intervals for 6 months to determine outcome because subsequent diagnostic management was at the discretion of practicing physicians. By 6 months, 84% of patients with abnormal findings had seen a physician as recommended. Of the 76 with abnormal DRE only, 11 were biopsied and only one cancer was found (9%). Of 48 with an elevated PSA only, 19 were biopsied; 11 (58%) had cancer (9/9 positive transrectal ultrasound) and 8 had no cancer at biopsy (5/5 negative transrectal ultrasound). Of 21 with both tests suspicious, 11 were biopsied and 9 had cancer (82%). Thus, by 6 months after each screen there was a 3.5% overall cancer detection rate for the whole population screened, a 67% positive biopsy rate among those with an elevated PSA, a 45% positive biopsy detection rate among those with an abnormal DRE, and a 51% positive biopsy rate among all those biopsied. Eighty percent of the PSA elevations were between 4.1 and 10.0 ng/ml. This screening experience yielded several new diagnoses of prostate cancer, and the use of serum PSA levels and ultrasound-guided biopsy was associated with a high positive biopsy rate for cancer.