Surgical interventions in ischemic ventricular tachyarrhythmias--endocardial resection or implanted...

The surgical therapy of ventricular tachyarrhythmias (VTA) in ischemic heart disease is attracting attention, since current medical therapies are showing limited long-term efficacy. The curative concept of electrophysiologically guided endocardial resection (ER) and palliation with the implantable cardioverter/defibrillator (ICD) are compared retrospectively. From 1980-1992, 121 patients (55 +/- 9 years, 108 males, 13 females) underwent ER and 203 patients (59 +/- 9 years, 195 males, 8 females) received an ICD for ischemic VTA. Concomitant coronary revascularization was performed in 38/121 patients with ER (31%) and in 62/203 patients (31%) with ICD. Perioperative mortality was 8% (10/121 patients) for ER and 5% (10/203 patients) for ICD (P = n.s.). Hundred eleven patients with ER (mean follow-up 41 +/- 37 months) and 193 with ICD (mean follow-up 22 +/- 20 months) were available for survival analysis: freedom from sudden death was comparable for the two groups at 1 year (99% for ICD, and 94% for ER) and at 5 years (90% for ICD and 90% for ER) (P = n.s.). Freedom from cardiac death also showed no differences between the groups at 1 year (94% for ICD, and 84% for ER) and at 5 years (74% for ICD and 74% for ER) (P = n.s.). Left ventricular function, indicated by left ventricular ejection fraction, was comparable (34 +/- 9% in ER, 30 +/- 11% with ICD) (P = n.s.) in the two groups. The linearized incidence of DC-shocks was 10.3/year in ICD patients.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)