Terminal base pairs of oligodeoxynucleotides: imino proton exchange and fraying

We have estimated the dissociation constant of the terminal base pairs of the B-DNA duplexes formed by 5'-d(CGCGATCGCG) and 5'-d(TAGCGCTA) by two methods, one based on the change in imino proton chemical shift with temperature and the other on the apparent pK shift of the imino proton, as monitored by the change in chemical shift of aromatic protons. These methods do not rely on imino proton exchange, whose rate was also measured. (1) The effect of ammonia on the imino proton exchange rate of the terminal pair of the 5'-d(CGCGATCGCG) duplex is 67 times less than on the isolated nucleoside. This provides an upper limit on the exchange rate from the closed pair. In fact, the effect is just as predicted from the dissociation constant, assuming that there is no exchange at all from the closed pair and that, as has been argued previously, external catalysts act on the open state as they do on the isolated nucleoside. The inhibition of catalyzed proton exchange in the closed pair, despite exposure of one face of the pair to solvent, is a new feature of the exchange process. It will allow determination of the dissociation constant of terminal pairs from the exchange rate. (2) Intrinsic catalysis of proton exchange is less efficient for the terminal pair than for an internal one. A possible explanation is that proton transfer across the water bridge responsible for intrinsic catalysis is slower, as expected if the open-state separation of the bases is larger in a terminal pair. This observation may lead to a direct method for the study of fraying. (3) At 0 degrees C, the dissociation constant of the second pair of the 5'-d(CGCGATCGCG) duplex is close to the square of the constant for the terminal pair, as predicted from a simple model of fraying. The enthalpy and entropy of opening of the terminal pairs may be compared with those of nearest neighbor interactions derived from calorimetry [Breslauer, K. J., et al. (1986) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 83, 3746-3750].