Varying neurological phenotypes among muto and mut- patients with methylmalonylCoA mutase deficiency

MethylmalonylCoA mutase (MCM) is a mitochondrial homodimer responsible for the isomerization of methylmalonylCoA to succinylCoA. Apomutase defects are traditionally divided into muto and mut- classes on the basis of residual mutase activity. Clinical findings were reviewed in 20 patients with methylmalonic aciduria secondary to MCM deficiency. All 11 muto patients had an early neonatal presentation; 6 of these patients died in infancy and 3 of 5 survivors had a poor neurological outcome as evidenced by severe delay or spastic quadriparesis with dystonia. The 2 other survivors include a 27-month-old child with a mild delay in verbal and fine motor skills and an adolescent with low normal intelligence. Of the 9 mut- patients, 7 became symptomatic in late infancy or childhood and 2 were picked up on screening. Two of the 9 patients have never had an episode of metabolic decompensation yet both are neurologically compromised; one severely retarded and autistic, the other mildly delayed. Four mut- patients have had episodic acidosis and are neurologically moderately affected, while 3 have had episodic acidosis and are neurologically intact. These results confirm phenotypic pleomorphism without a consistent pattern of neurological injury and suggest some broad correlation between mutase class and phenotype. Survival with good outcome is possible among muto patients as is significant morbidity among mut- patients. Acidosis and metabolic imbalance are not necessary preconditions for significant morbidity.