Problems associated with estimation of net calcium uptake during enamel formation using 45Ca

45Ca uptake in mineralizing tissues may occur by net Ca uptake or by isotopic exchange. It is rarely possible to differentiate between these effects, making interpretation of the findings difficult. Unfortunately, this problem is not often considered, and 45Ca uptake is usually regarded as representative of only net calcium uptake. The study reported here was undertaken to estimate the extent to which 45Ca uptake in mineralizing enamel is due to net Ca deposition or to isotopic exchange, and to consider the implications. The enamel surfaces of the lower incisors of adult rats were notched at the gingival line, and the eruption distance over 16 hours was measured. This distance was used to establish the position of a 0.3-mm-wide increment of enamel at the beginning and end of the 16-hour period, during which it passed through the early-maturation stage of enamel formation. The rate of Ca uptake was determined by chemical assay. Other rats were injected with 45Ca, mean plasma specific activity values for the experimental period determined, and the rate of Ca uptake through the same area of enamel formation was estimated. The estimates were from two- to nearly ten-fold greater than those established by chemical assay, indicating that from 50 to 90% of the 45Ca uptake occurred by isotopic exchange. 45Ca uptake may indicate more about the labile state of Ca in mineralizing enamel than about the rate of mineral deposition.