Human adjuvant disease revisited: a review of eleven post-augmentation mammoplasty patients

We have reviewed 11 women post-augmentation mammoplasty who were referred to our clinic with diffuse rheumatic complaints. All patients had undergone mammoplasty with silicone gel-filled implants prior to the onset of their locomotor symptoms (mean latency time 7.8 years). One physician interviewed and examined each of these patients following a standardized format for clinical retrieval.

Of the patients reviewed, 6 patients had clinical fibromyalgia based on the ACR criteria, and the remaining 5 patients had symptoms consistent with the "chronic fatigue syndrome." None of our patients were found to have evidence of a defined connective tissue disease. Antinuclear antibodies were detected in 4 (36%) patients and low level titres of extractable nuclear antigens in only 2 (18%).

Previously a causal relationship between the use of silicone gel-filled breast implants and the subsequent development of symptoms referred to as human adjuvant disease (HAD) has been proposed. On the basis of currently accepted criteria we have preferred to diagnose our post-mammoplasty patients without specific connective tissue disease, as having chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), or when tender points are present, as having fibromyalgia (FMS), rather than implying that such cases represent a separate and unique rheumatological disease entity. In the light of our current understanding of CFS and FMS, a relationship between them and the previous silicone mammoplasty seems possible.