Improving resectability and survival in patients with primary duodenal carcinoma

Of 35 patients with primary duodenal carcinoma (PDC), 13 were treated between 1960 and 1974 (group I) and 22 between 1975 and 1990 (group II). PDCs were found in the first 5 portions of the duodenum (14%), second 18 (51%), third 8 (23%), and fourth 4 (12%). Five patients (38%) in group I were deemed to have unresectable disease compared with only one patient (5%) in group II. Eight patients (62%) in group I underwent resection by either pancreatoduodenectomy (4) or segmental resection (4), and 20 patients (95%) in group II had pancreatoduodenectomy (17) or segmental resection (3). Operative mortality was 31% in group I and 0% in group II. Mean survival was 7 months (range: 0 to 22 months) in group I and 48 months (range: 6 to 218 months) in group II. None of the patients in group I survived for 2 years, whereas the 5-year survival for patients in group II was 62%. This experience suggests that resectability, operative mortality, and survival in patients with PDCs have improved markedly in recent years.