The induction of peripheral tolerance by the chronic activation and deletion of CD4+V beta 5+ cells

In C57BL/6 mice transgenic for a rearranged gene encoding a V beta 5+ beta-chain of the TCR, transgene expression among CD4+ cells decreases with age, such that approximately 40% of CD4+ cells express an endogenous beta-chain gene in 8-mo-old mice. A similar deletion of V beta 5+ cells is observed among CD4+ cells from nontransgenic littermates. V beta 5+ T cells are deleted intrathymically in I-E+Mtv-9+ strains of mice, but this chronic deletion occurs in the lymphoid periphery, in the absence of I-E. We now demonstrate the increased expression of the activation markers CD44 and VLA-4 among CD4+V beta 5+ cells, in the absence of either an increase in size or IL-2 receptor expression. Functional as well as phenotypic differences distinguish CD4+ from CD8+ cells in older V beta 5+ transgenic mice. Relative to their CD8+ counterparts, CD4+V beta 5+ cells are hyporesponsive to plate-bound anti-V beta 5 Abs, and this anergy is partially reversible by the addition of exogenous IL-2. These data suggest the deletion of CD4+V beta 5+ cells is the result of a process that includes their activation, loss of function, and their eventual removal. To investigate the involvement of the principal V beta 5 superantigen Mtv-9 in this chronic deletion, we have derived several lines of V beta 5+I-E-Mtv-9- mice. Transgene expression also declines with age in CD4+ T cells in these mice, clearly demonstrating that the chronic deletion of CD4+V beta 5+ cells does not require Mtv-9. There is considerable variation in the kinetics and efficiency of CD4+V beta 5+ deletion between lines of Mtv-9- transgenic mice that is not from differences in the profiles of endogenous mammary tumor proviruses nor readily explained by environmental differences that influence proviral expression. These results suggest the existence of genetic factors other than mammary tumor proviruses that influence the deletion of CD4+V beta 5+ cells in the absence of I-E.