Effect of lung inflation and sternotomy direction on pleural space violation

Patients often are disconnected temporarily from the ventilator before sternotomy to avoid entering the pleural space with the sternal saw. Although this practice is widespread, it is based on questionable physiologic principles. To evaluate the efficacy of this maneuver in reducing the incidence of pleural space violation with first-time sternotomy, 126 cardiac patients were randomized prospectively to either lungs inflated or deflated during sternotomy with the surgeon blinded to the particular assignment. The incidence of pleural space violation overall was 12%, occurring in 15% of patients with deflated lungs and in 9% of those with inflated lungs (p = 0.455 by chi 2 test). Examining the effect of the direction of sternotomy on pleural space entry revealed a 4% incidence with sternotomy starting at the xiphoid versus a 21% incidence with sternotomy starting at the sternal notch (p = 0.009 by chi 2 test). Preexisting hyperinflation of the lungs as evaluated by chest radiograms did not influence the incidence of pleural space violation. To reduce pleural space violation, sternotomy should be performed from the xiphoid to the sternal notch. More importantly, disconnecting the patient from the ventilator does not reduce pleural space violation with sternotomy and its further use is not indicated. These findings are discussed in the context of relevant heart-lung pathophysiology.