Stability against denaturation mechanisms in halophilic malate dehydrogenase "adapt" to solvent conditions

Malate dehydrogenase from Haloarcula marisomortui (hMDH) is active, soluble and mildly unstable in an unusually wide range of salt conditions and temperatures, making it a particularly interesting model for the study of solvent effects on protein stability. Its denaturation (loss of activity due to concomitant dissociation and unfolding) kinetics was studied as a function of temperature and concentration of NaCl, potassium phosphate or ammonium sulphate in H2O or 2H2O. A transition-state-theory analysis was applied to the data. In all cases, stability (resistance to denaturation) increased with increasing salt concentration, and when 2H2O replaced H2O. Each salt condition was associated with a particular energy regime that dominated stability. In NaCl/H2O, a positive enthalpy term, delta H not equal to 0, always dominated the activation free energy of denaturation, delta G not equal to 0. In potassium phosphate/H2O and ammonium sulphate/H2O, on the other hand, stability was dominated by a negative activation entropy, delta S not equal to 0. and delta H not equal to 0 changed sign between 10 degrees C and 20 degrees C, consistent with a strong hydrophobic effect contribution, in these salting-out solvents. Decreasing stability at low temperatures, favouring cold denaturation, was observed. Replacing H2O by 2H2O strengthened the hydrophobic effect in all conditions. As a consequence, conditions were found in which hMDH was not halophilic; below 10 degrees C, it was stable in approximately 0.1 M NaCl/2H2O. The solution structure and preferential solvent interactions of hMDH in H2O or 2H2O solvents containing NaCl were studied by densimetry and neutron scattering. Despite the different stability of the protein in H2O or 2H2O, an experimentally identical invariant solution particle was formed in both solvents. It had a total volume of 1.165 cm3 g-1 and bound about 0.4 g of H2O (0.44 g of 2H2O) and about 0.08 g NaCl g protein. The impact of these results on a stabilisation model for hMDH, involving ion binding, is discussed.