Mammographic film density and detection of small breast cancers

From its inception, the UK National Breast Screening Programme (NHSBSP) has recognized that optimum image quality of the mammographic screening test is a key objective. The overall optical density of the mammography film is one of the factors expected to have a significant effect on the image quality of the mammogram with the potential to influence cancer detection. In a previous review of the performance of mammography equipment in the NHSBSP, it was observed that there was a very wide range in the mammographic film densities used at different breast screening centres. In this study a mammography test object was used to show experimentally that, for a typical mammography system, image quality increased substantially with increased film density. Summary data was therefore requested from radiologists in the NHSBSP on the rate of detection of small invasive cancers (diam. < or = 10 mm) and the typical film density used during that year. Proforma were completed for 61 annual sets of results from 31 screening centres involving over 500,000 women. Where centres reported using film densities of less than 1.2D the average small cancer detection rate was 0.12% +/- 0.01%, as compared to an average of 0.17% +/- 0.01% for centres using higher film densities. The results indicate that there is a need for national guidelines in the setting of film densities, and a range for target film densities of 1.4D to 1.8D has been suggested. Attention to optimizing image quality by increasing film density is of particular importance to any screening centre where film densities of less than 1.2D are used, as there may be the potential to increase the detection of small breast cancers by as much as 50%.