Comparison of large-conductance Ca(2+)-activated K+ channels in artificial bilayer and patch-clamp experiments

We compared the gating, ion conduction, and pharmacology of large-conductance Ca(2+)-activated K+ channels (BK channels) from canine colon in artificial lipid bilayers and in excised patches. Both protocols identified 270-pS K(+)-selective channels activated by depolarization and Ca2+ (approximately 130-mV shift of half-activation voltage per 10-fold change in Ca2+) that were inhibited by extracellular tetraethylammonium (TEA) and charybdotoxin. These similarities suggest that the same BK channels are studied in the two techniques. However, we found three quantitative differences between channels in artificial bilayers and patches. 1) Channels in artificial bilayers required fivefold higher free Ca2+ or 80-mV stronger depolarization for activation. 2) The voltage dependence of TEA block was smaller for channels in artificial bilayers. The apparent distance across the membrane field for the TEA binding site was 0.031 for channels in artificial bilayers and 0.23 for channels in patches. 3) ATP (2 mM) decreased open probability (Po) of channels in artificial bilayers, whereas channels in patches were unaffected. Neither GTP nor UTP reduced Po of channels in artificial bilayers. It is possible that these differences may be due to a lack of molecular identity between the channels studied in the two protocols. Alternatively, they may be attributed to alterations in channel properties during reconstitution or to influences of the artificial lipid environment.