Related Experiment Video
Updated: Oct 24, 2026
Inverse Probability of Treatment Weighting (Propensity Score) using the Military Health System Data Repository and National Death Index
Published on: January 8, 2020
Rationing or rationalizing children's medical care: comparison of a Medicaid HMO with fee-for-service care
J Mauldon1, A Leibowitz, J L Buchanan
1Graduate School of Public Policy, University of California at Berkeley.
Insights
Medicaid Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) provide comparable checkups but fewer acute care visits for children compared to fee-for-service plans. This suggests potential savings without compromising care for vulnerable populations.
Area of Science:
- Health Services Research
- Pediatric Healthcare Delivery
- Public Health Policy
Background:
- Medicaid beneficiaries often face challenges accessing consistent medical care.
- Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) offer an alternative delivery model to traditional fee-for-service (FFS) arrangements.
- Understanding care variations between Medicaid HMOs and FFS is crucial for optimizing child health outcomes.
Purpose of the Study:
- To compare the medical care received by children enrolled in a Medicaid HMO versus those under traditional fee-for-service (FFS) Medicaid.
- To assess differences in healthcare utilization and service targeting based on the payment model.
Main Methods:
- A randomized trial design was employed, assigning Medicaid households to either an HMO or a traditional FFS plan.
- Participating households meticulously recorded data on their children's health status and medical care utilization.
- Analysis focused on comparing visit types, service content, and emergency room usage between the two groups.
Main Results:
- Children in the Medicaid HMO and FFS groups received a similar number of well-child checkups.
- HMO enrollees experienced significantly fewer acute care visits compared to FFS recipients.
- The study observed no significant differences in the content of health visits or emergency room utilization between the two systems.
Conclusions:
- Medicaid HMOs can be structured to achieve cost savings without negatively impacting care for vulnerable children.
- While promising, these findings do not yet support broad policy shifts towards Medicaid HMOs.
- Further research is essential to determine if health outcomes differ between children receiving care through Medicaid HMOs versus FFS models.
Objectives:
This paper examines how medical care obtained by children enrolled in a Medicaid health maintenance organization (HMO) differs from that obtained by similar children who receive care from fee-for-service Medicaid providers.
Methods:
In a randomized trial, some Medicaid households were assigned to remain in a traditional fee-for-service arrangement and others were randomly selected to join a Medicaid prepaid plan (an HMO). Participating households recorded data on children's health status and use of medical care.
Results:
The prepaid plan members and the fee-for-service recipients received equivalent numbers of checkup visits, but the children in the prepaid plan made significantly fewer acute care visits. This plan appeared to target its services to children with the greatest health care needs. However, the content of health visits in the two systems did not differ, nor did prepaid and fee-for-service enrollees use the emergency room differently.
Conclusions:
It is possible to design a Medicaid HMO that achieves financial savings without reducing services to the most vulnerable patients. However, these findings alone do not provide a basis for widespread policy change in the direction of Medicaid HMOs. Further research is needed to establish whether the children treated in the HMO differed in health outcomes from those treated by fee-for-service care.
Related Concept Videos
01:18Introduction To Health Care Delivery System
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) advocates for a patient-centered, effective, safe, timely, equitable, and effective healthcare system. The National Priorities...
01:26Methods Of Healthcare Delivery System
Managed Care System:
The managed care system is designed to control the cost while maintaining the quality of care. The patient's care from admission to discharge is planned by the primary care provider or the case manager, also known as the gatekeeper. In a managed care system, the number of care providers is limited...
01:20Integrated Healthcare System
01:15Methods of Documentation VI: Case Management Model
For example, a patient with a chronic illness...
01:30Health Information Technology and Healthcare Information System
Health Information Technology, commonly called HIT, integrates advanced information systems and technology in healthcare settings. Its primary functions include:
01:29Drug Dosing: Infants and Children