The left-sided predominance of asbestos-related pleural disease

In a series of 406 subjects with a diagnosis of asbestos-related pleural disease (ARPD), the left-right symmetry of radiographically diagnosed ARPD was assessed using the International Labour Organization (ILO) system for classifying radiographic abnormalities and three different statistical models for testing the degree of symmetry. The extent of chest disease was found to be greater on the left than on the right for a number of parameters of pleural disease, including the width and extent of localized pleural thickening, the extent of enface pleural thickening, and the extent of diaphragmatic and chest wall calcification. Current cigarette smoking significantly enhanced the observed asymmetry, with the most pronounced effect being in diaphragmatic calcification. Using a composite scale for each subject's pleural disease, the left side had 1.6 times more localized disease than did the right (p < 0.001). Asymmetry in one parameter was associated with asymmetry in another for a number of pairs. The most significant of these associations was between enface pleural thickening and chest wall calcification (Kendall's tau B = 0.42). The pathophysiologic mechanisms that explain these findings remain elusive and need further investigation.