Evidence against a relationship between fatty acid ethyl ester synthase and the Pi class glutathione S-transferase in...

Recently, Bora et al. (Bora, P. S., Bora, N. S., Wu, X., and Lange, L. G. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 16774-16777) reported the cloning and expression of a human fatty acid ethyl ester synthase III (FAEES-III) cDNA that has only four amino acid substitutions compared with human glutathione S-transferase (GST) GSTP1-1, and, when expressed in MCF-7 cells, the protein has both FAEES and GST activities. By site-directed mutagenesis of a GSTP1 cDNA, we have constructed a clone that encodes the FAEES-III protein described by Bora et al. (1991). The recombinant FAEES-III protein was expressed in Escherichia coli and has been shown to be devoid of FAEES and GST activities. The recombinant FAEES-III protein does not bind to a glutathione agarose affinity matrix, presumably because two of the substituted amino acids, Trp-39-->Cys and Gln-52-->Glu, are thought to contribute to the GST glutathione binding site. One of the base substitutions in the FAEES-III cDNA encodes an extra SacI site not found in the GSTPI cDNA. Polymerase chain reaction amplification of human genomic DNA has identified the GSTPI gene, but no DNA from the proposed FAEES gene with a diagnostic SacI site has been detected. Evaluation of the hybridization pattern of HindIII genomic restriction fragments has identified fragments that contain the GSTPI gene and a pseudogene (Board et al. 1992), and there do not appear to be any hybridizing fragments that could contain the FAEES-III gene. Our results do not provide any evidence in support of a relationship between FAEES-III and GST, and the cDNA reported by Bora et al. (1991) may have resulted from a cloning artifact.