Early open mitral commissurotomy: long-term results

It has frequently been suggested that early mitral commissurotomy could improve long-term results in patients with severe mitral stenosis. However, the real advantages of this procedure have yet to be demonstrated. To evaluate this hypothesis, we retrospectively studied 397 patients who underwent operation for mitral stenosis in our unit between 1978 and 1988. Forty of these patients (group I) fulfilled the criteria for early mitral commissurotomy: being young (average age 33 years), being asymptomatic or showing few symptoms, and being in sinus rhythm. The remaining 357 patients who underwent operation during the same period of time served as control (group II). Mitral valve replacement (p < 0.05) and associated tricuspid annuloplasty (p < 0.05) occurred less frequently in patients from group I than it did in patients from group II. Survival after 11 years for patients with early mitral commissurotomy was 100%, 90% of whom were in functional class I, were in sinus rhythm, and were receiving no medication whatsoever. Ninety-six percent of these patients were free of complications after 11 years, compared with 73% of patients in group II (p < 0.05). In our opinion, these results support the use of early mitral commissurotomy for young patients in sinus rhythm, who are symptom free, who are and who have a mitral valve area is 1.3 cm2 or less.