Repeated hepatic resections for colorectal metastases

Repeated hepatic resection (RHR) for recurrent colorectal metastases remains uncommon and controversial. We report our experience in order to assess the feasibility and the potential oncologic benefit of such an aggressive management. From 1981 to 1991, 13 patients underwent a RHR. The first hepatic resection had been an anatomic hepatectomy removing between two and six segments in 10 patients and a wedge resection in three. The RHR was performed after a mean delay of 16 +/- 10 months (5-35) from the first liver procedure. The RHR was an anatomic hepatectomy in eight patients (including a right hepatectomy in three) and a minor resection (tumorectomy or segmentectomy) in five. Three patients underwent a third liver resection for recurrence. There was no post-operative mortality. Eleven patients died from recurrence after a mean survival of 17 +/- 13 months from the second hepatic procedure (range: 6-47). One patient died from unrelated disease after 12 months and one was alive free of recurrence 22, 53 and 84 months after third, second and first hepatectomy respectively. The median survivals from the second and first hepatic resections were 17 and 31 months, respectively. It is concluded that in the well-trained team, RHR is feasible and safe even after major primary hepatectomy. However the oncologic benefit remains questionable.