Ethmoidal cancers: a retrospective study of 22 cases

From April 1978 to June 1990, 22 patients with ethmoidal cancer were treated at Fondation Bergonié by a combination of surgery and radiation therapy. The mean age was 59.6 years (range 34-79 years) and the sex ratio is 2.7 (16 males/6 females). Histologic types were: adenocarcinoma, 13 cases; squamous carcinoma, 4 cases; undifferentiated carcinoma, 3 cases and esthesioneuroblastoma, 2 cases. Exposure to wood dust was encountered in 11 patients, especially in cases of adenocarcinoma: 10/13 (77%). Staging according to the classification of the University of Florida was: Stage I, 10 patients; Stage II, 5 patients and Stage III, 7 patients. Resection was considered as complete in 16 cases and only one orbital exenteration was performed. The postoperative radiation therapy delivered a mean given dose of 55.7 Gy (range 50-70 Gy) expressed to the hot spot using a technique adapted to tumor location and extension. Complete remission was achieved in 20 cases. Median follow-up is 28 months. The 5-year overall and disease-free survival are 44% and 38%, respectively. Analysis of recurrences according to staging gives: 5/10 Stage I, 2/5 Stage II and 5/7 Stage III. Recurrence is pejorative since death occurs in all cases within an average of 6 months following salvage treatment, except for three patients still alive within less than 6 months and in second remission. Prognosis of ethmoidal cancer depends on staging and local control.