A biomechanical analysis of short segment spinal fixation using a three-dimensional geometric and mechanical model

Vertebral stabilization using spinal fixation devices is a widely used technique. A three-dimensional geometric and mechanical finite element model has been used as a simulation tool for the evaluation of the mechanical behavior of spinal devices. The geometry of lumbar vertebrae was parameterized, which allows the construction of the geometric model for a given lumbar segment from the digitization of two roentgenographs. This procedure was used to construct a finite element model for a three-vertebra segment with simulation of fractures in the middle vertebra, and with simulation of a restoration using an osteosynthesis device, implemented in a frame fashion with four screws and two rods linked by two transverse rods, and/or an anterior bone graft. Compression force and torsion moment were considered, and different cases were investigated, by varying the severity of the fracture, the geometric characteristics of the device, and the mechanical characteristics of the material joining the two intact vertebral bodies. Results were analyzed considering the mobility of the vertebral segment, which indicates the ability of the restoration system to stabilize the vertebral segment, and considering the forces and moments distribution in the device, which gives information on part of the forces that pass through the device in each situation. Results show that maximum values of forces and moments in the device are more important in compression than in torsion. Adding an anterior bone graft has an effect mainly for compression, whereas in torsion its effect is negligible. For a rigid fixation device, no significant difference was found between different fracture models, indicating that the posterior arch does not play an important role for an instrumented segment. For compression, a rigid posterior wall, or the presence of a bone graft, reduces greatly the mobility of the instrumented segment. For torsion, suppressing the two transverse rods in the device greatly increases the mobility of the instrumented segment. Using a finite element model of a lumbar vertebral segment appears to be an interesting tool to analyze the behavior of an instrumented spine and to compare between different stabilization systems.