Skeletal muscle lipids and glycogen mask substrate competition (Randle cycle)

The glucose-free fatty acid (FFA) cycle (Randle) was examined in soleus muscle, a red muscle with a high lipid oxidation rate, and extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscle, a white muscle with a low lipid oxidation rate, using a carnitine palmethyltransferase (CPT-I) inhibitor as a probe. Exogenous palmitate by itself had little if any effect on glycolysis or glycogen accumulation in the two muscle types. The CPT-I inhibitor markedly decreased glycogen accumulation in both muscles (from fed rats), but increased glycolysis (lactate formation) and glucose oxidation to carbon dioxide only in the red muscle. When the muscles were made more dependent on FFA oxidation by prior fasting or exercise, the CPT-I stimulatory effect on glycolysis and glucose oxidation in white muscle was unmasked. In conclusion, the competition between lipid and carbohydrate utilization (Randle cycle) is easily demonstrated in both red and white muscle using a CPT-I inhibitor as a probe. The difficulties encountered in showing this competition in other studies using exogenous FFA may be explained by a combination of factors, including (1) low tissue lipid oxidation rates, (2) competition between exogenous and endogenous lipids such that provision of exogenous lipids fails to increase overall lipid oxidation, and (3) preferential utilization of exogenous glucose with glycogen sparing in the presence of FFA.