Optimal number of chemotherapy courses in advanced nonseminomatous testicular carcinoma

Nonseminomatous germ cell tumors (NSGCT) (testicular carcinoma) are a curable disease. Stages I and II are nearly 100% curable. Stage III has had remarkable progress in attaining complete regression, but a substantial number fail to be cured. Using platinum-based regimens such as vinblastine, bleomycin, and cisplatin (VBP), or using etoposide instead of vinblastine (BEP), or without bleomycin (EP), four courses of chemotherapy have become a national standard. Based on our prior experience with mithramycin (plicamycin), which used six courses, six courses of VBP chemotherapy were utilized as our treatment goal. This report challenges the concept that "standard therapy" for stage III testicular carcinoma is four courses.

From 1976 to 1990, 74 patients with advanced NSGCT were treated with standard doses of plantinum-based chemotherapies. Five or more courses were delivered to 41 patients and fewer than five courses to 33 patients. The intent of therapy was to attain as close to six courses as possible. Because of physician preference, patient adherence, or toxicity, some patients did not reach that goal.

Of 33 patients receiving less than five courses, there were 28 (85%) complete responders, and 26 (78.8%) are alive. Of 41 patients receiving five or more courses, 38 (92.7%) had complete responses, and 34 (83%) are alive. One person in each group is living with nonresectable teratoma present. In the group receiving 5+ courses, two died from causes unrelated to testis cancer and had no testis cancer present. As a result of the initial treatment, there was no evidence of cancer in 24 (72.8%) in the group receiving less than five courses and 35 (85.4%) had no cancer after five or more courses. In considering only patients with advanced level of stage III disease in contrast to minimal or moderate stage III disease, there were fewer complete regressions with less than five courses (64.3%) than with five or more courses (88.0%).

For minimal stage III disease, four courses of chemotherapy may be adequate. For advanced stage III disease, more chemotherapy provides fewer treatment failures. Once a complete response is achieved without restriction to an arbitrary number of courses, two additional courses may constitute a more curative regimen.