Comparison of cleft and papillary muscle position in cleft mitral valve and atrioventricular septal defect

Differentiation of cleft mitral valve from atrioventricular septal defect (AVSD) is surgically important because of different conduction pathways. The purpose of this study was to find echocardiographic markers for differentiating cleft mitral valve from AVSD. We examined 11 children with cleft mitral valve, 11 children with AVSD, and 11 normal children. We defined a fixed reference point (0 degrees of arc) at the medial junction of the right ventricular free wall with the posteroinferior ventricular septum. Left ventricular papillary muscle and cleft position was measured clockwise in degrees of arc from 0 degrees around a point representing the center of the left ventricle in the parasternal short-axis views. Mural leaflet size was expressed by the arc between the bases of the papillary muscles. Papillary muscle position in cleft mitral valve was similar to that in normals (anterolateral ventricular papillary muscle:cleft mitral valve 194 +/- 10 degrees, normals 191 +/- 8 degrees; posteromedial ventricular papillary muscle:cleft mitral valve 329 +/- 10 degrees, normals 329 +/- 14 degrees). In AVSD, both left ventricular papillary muscles originated closer to each other and were rotated counterclockwise (anterolateral papillary muscle: 182 +/- 7 degrees; posteromedial papillary muscle: 287 degrees +/- 17 degrees). The mural leaflet size was similar in cleft mitral valve and in normal children. In AVSD, the mural leaflet was significantly smaller than in cleft mitral valve and in normals. The cleft position did not permit distinction between cleft mitral valve and AVSD. In conclusion, echocardiographic measurements of papillary muscle position and mural leaflet size permit differentiation of cleft mitral valve from AVSD.