One-stage versus two-stage Soave pull-through for Hirschsprung's disease in the first year of life

Several investigators have reported good results after a one-stage Soave procedure without a stoma for infants with Hirschsprung's disease. The authors reviewed their concurrent experience with the one- and two-stage approaches, comparing the two groups with respect to rate of complications and clinical outcome. Over a 3-year period, 36 infants with colonic Hirschsprung's disease presenting in the first year of life were treated with a Soave pull-through. Thirteen had a one-stage pull-through, and 23 had a two-stage procedure using an initial stoma. There was no difference with respect to median age at time of diagnosis, median follow-up period, length of aganglionosis, or male:female ratio between the groups. The incidences of major complications such as small bowel obstruction, segmental or acquired aganglionosis, anastomotic leak, and malabsorption were equal between the two groups. However, 13% of the two-stage patients required revision of the stoma. All major complications in the one-stage group were in those who weighed less than 4 kg at the time of surgery. Minor complications such as wound infection, perianal excoriation, and need for repeated dilatation were similar between the groups, but minor stoma-related complications (prolapse or retraction) occurred in 26% of the two-stage infants. When complications were stratified using a more sophisticated scale of severity, no significant difference was found between the groups. The overall complication rate was 1.5 events per patient in the one-stage group and 2.0 events per patient in the two-stage group. This small difference was related to the presence of a stoma in the two-stage group. Overall, 10 of 12 survivors in the one-stage group and 22 of 23 in the two-stage group were doing well, with normal bowel function noted on long-term follow-up (mean period, of 14 and 19 months, respectively). Both one- and two-stage approaches were associated with a significant complication rate, although long-term outcome was excellent in both groups. The higher complication rate in the two-stage group was attributable to the presence of a stoma. For small infants, it may be beneficial to delay the one-stage pull-through until weight exceeds 4 kg.