A noninvasive evaluation of baroreceptor sensitivity with the Valsalva maneuver and phenylephrine methods

In a double-blind crossover study, we compared baroreceptor sensitivity (BS) and latency, derived from the phenylephrine method with BS and latency derived from phase IV of the Valsalva maneuver (VM), using the Finapres, a noninvasive blood pressure monitor. Ten healthy volunteers were enrolled in the study and BS was determined with placebo, atropine (0.03 mg/kg) and atenolol (10 mg) and was expressed as the linear relation between the change in RR interval following the blood pressure rise induced by either phenylephrine or phase IV of the VM (i.e., after cessation of straining). Baseline baroreceptor sensitivity (p<0.001) and baroreceptor sensitivity in the presence of atropine (p<0.02) was smaller with the VM but no differences in baroreceptor sensitivity between the two methods were evident after atenolol. Although no linearity existed between the two methods under any of the experimental conditions, baroreceptor sensitivity in the presence of atropine was significantly smaller (p<0.01)(and latency delayed (p<0.08)) compared to atenolol-induced changes with both methods. We found excellent correlation between baroreceptor sensitivity derived from the ECG tracing and Finapres recorded beat-to-beat pulse intervals (p<0.001; r>0.8, under all conditions) although the correlation after atropine was not as close (p<0.01; r=0.7). The smaller baroreceptor sensitivity induced by the Valsalva maneuver with placebo and atropine, but not with atenolol, suggests a parasympathetically influenced vasodilation, and sympathetically medicated tachycardia during phase IV of the VM.