Clonality of basal cell carcinoma--molecular analysis of an interesting case

Tumor cells represent a single clone of cells that have undergone a series of mutations in genomic DNA. This process, known as clonal evolution, is a distinguishing feature of cancer. The human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA; GenBank) contains a highly polymorphic cytosine-adenine-guanine trinucleotide repeat that can be used to determine clonality by depicting X chromosome inactivation patterns. Random X chromosome inactivation is consistent with polyclonality; nonrandom X chromosome inactivation indicates a clonal population of cells. Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) demonstrates an atypical growth pattern in that it grows slowly, rarely metastasizes, and is rarely lethal. Whether this tumor results from the accumulation of mutations in a single cell with subsequent clonal expansion or reflects a polyclonal response by a group of cells to a growth stimulus is unknown. To provide further insight into the molecular events characterizing BCCs, we determined the clonal origin of five modular BCCs from a female patient by analyzing X chromosome inactivation patterns at the HUMARA locus. All tumors demonstrated a nonrandom pattern of X chromosome inactivation, consistent with monoclonal proliferation. These findings provide strong genetic evidence that sporadic BCCs develop by clonal evolution and support the contention that a series of mutations in a single cell is responsible for the altered growth state seen in these transformed epithelial cells.