A stereological study of substantia nigra in young and old rhesus monkeys

The number of pigmented and non-pigmented neurons in the substantia nigra (SN) of 10 old and six young female Macaca mulatta monkeys and in three old alpha male monkeys were estimated using new stereological cell counting methods. No systematic right-left differences were noted, nor were old animals different from young ones with respect to SN volume (68.9 mm3 vs. 62.8 mm3) or absolute number of nerve cells (320,000 vs. 312,000). However, the total number of pigmented neurons was about eight times higher in old animals compared with young ones (166,000 vs. 21,400) while the total number of non-pigmented SN neurons was less than half in old animals compared with young ones (139,000 vs. 285,000). These differences create difficulties in generalizing experimental results from the rhesus animal model to man. It seems unlikely that a simple correlation can be made between pigmented and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) positive neurons in SN in monkeys. Instead of estimating the total number of pigmented and non-pigmented cells, only SN neurons positive for TH using immunohistochemical techniques might be used an indicator of the total number of dopaminergic neurons in SN in monkeys.