Muscle strength after successful total knee replacement: a 6- to 13-year followup

This study investigated the long term results of muscle strength of the knee joint after total knee replacement. Isokinetic testings of 120 degrees and 180 degrees per second and isometric testings at 30 degrees and 60 degrees knee flexion were studied on 1 healthy group and 3 groups of patients 6 to 13 years after total knee arthroplasty with prosthesis designs of total condylar, low contact stress meniscal bearing, or low contact stress rotating platform. The total condylar and low contact stress rotating platform prostheses were designed for use with a cut posterior cruciate ligament, whereas the low contact stress with meniscal bearing type was designed for use with a retained posterior cruciate ligament The muscle strength ratios of hamstring to quadriceps were compared among the prosthetic designs and there were no statistical differences among patient groups. Whether the posterior cruciate ligament was cut or retained did not affect the relative muscle strength of the quadriceps and hamstring. All hamstring to quadriceps ratios from the isokinetic testings of these 3 prostheses design groups were greater than those of the healthy group, but were quite close to those of patients with cut anterior cruciate ligaments or with lower levels of daily activity. The hamstring to quadriceps ratios after successful total knee replacement were not the same as those of the healthy group even after long term (6-13 years) functional adaptation.