Flow cytometric crossmatching in renal transplantation--the long-term outcome

The association of a positive flow cytometric crossmatch between recipient IgG directed against donor T lymphocytes and poor outcome is well described in renal transplantation. Until now no long-term follow-up on such patients has been available. In this study, 117 renal transplant patients were followed up for a period of 5 years. Of these 21 were known to have donor T cell directed IgG and five had B lymphocyte directed IgG. Both groups of patients with these antibodies had a significantly poorer outcome at 5 years than did the group of patients without IgG (p < 0.0001, Handel Maenzel test). Patients with antibody detected preoperatively were tested again either at the time of graft failure or at 5 years post-transplantation. The sera were tested against stored donor cells and the intensity of surface IgG compared with the preoperative levels. In those recipients who lost their grafts the levels increased in 60% of cases, but those who retained their grafts also had an increase in levels of donor directed antibody in 50% of cases. The changing levels of antibody therefore appeared to have little relevance to outcome. However when IgG isotypes were considered, in those who experienced graft failure and also had a gamma 3 isotype, a rise in IgG was demonstrated in all cases. Conversely, successful grafts with gamma 3 had a decline in levels between preoperative and 5-year samples in three of the four cases (not significant).