Greater frequency of K-ras Val-12 mutation in colorectal cancer as detected with sensitive methods

Assays for tumor mutations need to be sufficiently sensitive that a mutation can be readily detected in a high background of wild-type sequence. We have evaluated competitive allele-specific oligonucleotide (cASO) hybridization, the amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS), and a combination of cASO with mutant-enriched polymerase chain reaction (ME-PCR) for their respective sensitivities in detecting the K-ras Val-12 mutation. cASO hybridization detected 1 mutant allele in 100 wild-type alleles and identified 6 of 74 (8%) colorectal tumors as having the Val-12 mutation. ARMS detected 1 mutant in 1000 and 12 of 74 (16%) tumor samples, and the ME-PCR with cASO hybridization detected 1 in 5000 and 20 of 74 (27%) tumor samples. The mutation was not detected in normal bowel mucosa from selected Val-12 tumor-positive patients. ME-PCR combined with cASO resulted in a threefold higher detection rate than has previously been reported and suggests that other studies may have underestimated the frequency of K-ras mutations.