Heterogeneity in renal cell carcinoma and its impact no prognosis--a flow cytometric study

In the process of tumour progression genetic instability is the basis for the evolution of tumour cell clones with various genotypic and phenotypic characteristics causing heterogeneity. Renal cell carcinoma has a long prediagnostic growth period, which increases the probability of clonal evolution. We have studied 200 consecutive renal cell carcinomas, addressing the interrelationship between intratumour heterogeneity and clinicopathological factors. DNA ploidy patterns were analysed in multiple samples from each tumour using flow cytometry and compared with clinical stage, tumour invasion, metastatic rate and survival. Eighty-five of 192 evaluable tumours (44%) were homogeneous concerning DNA ploidy (62% diploid, 38% aneuploid). Among 107 heterogeneous tumours a majority (79%) contained aneuploid as well as diploid cell clones. Homogeneously diploid tumours had a lower incidence of local tumour spread compared with tumours with aneuploid cell clones (P < or = 0.001), but the frequency of distant metastasis at time of diagnosis was similar. The presence of aneuploidy in at least one sample from a tumour was a significant adverse prognostic factor (P < 0.001), whereas the degree of heterogeneity had no influence on survival. The frequent heterogeneity demonstrated indicates that multiple samples must be investigated to evaluate properly the malignant character of renal cell carcinoma.