Automated sputum screening with PAPNET system: a study of 122 cases

The use of interactive, computerized PAPNET system (Neuromedical Systems, Inc, Suffern, NY) for screening of cervicovaginal smears has been favorably evaluated in several studies. In this article, the authors report on the performance of this apparatus on smears of sputum. One hundred twenty-two randomly selected, single slides of sputum specimens from an equal number of patients were subjected to PAPNET scanning. These Papanicolaou-stained slides were previously classified as inadequate, six; negative, 81; atypical, three; suspicious, one; and positive for malignant cells, 31. Images selected by PAPNET were reviewed by two observers, who were blinded to earlier interpretation and triaged into two categories: negative and review. Of the 31 smears with cancer cells, 30 were appropriately identified by PAPNET (sensitivity: 97.1%). The only case missed by PAPNET was that of small cell carcinoma that contained a single cluster of neoplastic cells. PAPNET also triggered the review of 20 of the "negative" cases, which on re-evaluation were identified as bronchial cells with squamous metaplasia and altered benign squamous cells of inflammatory type. A prospective study of PAPNET for screening of sputum samples is needed to establish the clinical value of this methodology.