Sensitization and desensitization to capsaicin and menthol in the oral cavity: interactions and individual...

It was reported in a recent study that, like capsaicin, menthol is capable of producing a desensitization to sensory irritation in the oral cavity. Whereas capsaicin is known to be able to cross-desensitize with other chemical irritants, no such information exists for menthol. To address this question, the first experiment was designed to reveal whether cross-desensitization would occur between menthol and capsaicin. After a pretest on the tongue tip in which subjects rated the intensity of irritation and cold produced by 3.5 ppm capsaicin or 0.3% l-menthol, five samples of the same stimuli were sipped and swished at 1-min intervals for 5 min. Fifteen minutes later subjects were tested on the tongue tip with either capsaicin or menthol. The results 1) confirmed self-desensitization for both chemicals, 2) demonstrated cross-desensitization of menthol by capsaicin, and 3) revealed cross-sensitization of capsaicin by menthol. This series of outcomes suggests that menthol produces much of its sensory irritation via capsaicin-sensitive pathways, but that it excites and/or desensitizes those pathways via different mechanisms than does capsaicin. Analysis of the individual data revealed large differences in sensitization, and desensitization that were significantly correlated across chemicals, which suggests the possibility that the perceptual response to repeated exposures to irritants may be idiosyncratic. Contrary to earlier findings, the first experiment also revealed apparent self- and cross-desensitization of the menthol sensation of coolness. The latter outcome was investigated in a second experiment in which the effect of capsaicin desensitization on the perception of physical as well as chemical (menthol) cooling was measured when the stimuli were presented as oral rinses. No desensitization was found for either form of stimulation, which implied the apparent desensitization of coolness in Experiment I may have been due to the difficulty of discriminating sensations of cold from sensations of chemical irritation. The overall findings are discussed in terms of the complex sensory and perceptual interactions that take place within the chemesthetic modality.