Short-course therapy of pulmonary tuberculosis: doctor's compliance

The present study, conducted from 1986 to 1991, investigated the accuracy of treatment monitoring performed by practitioners in the out-patient treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis.

All patients with smear or culture positive pulmonary tuberculosis, receiving 6-month short-course chemotherapy with Isoniazid (H), Rifampicin (R) and Pyrazinamide (Z), were included. Treatment had been initiated either in our unit, or shortly before, with discharge after an average time of 8 weeks. Practitioners were sent a flow sheet advising how to perform standardized ambulatory controls.

Forty-three patients were included in the study, four of whom did not visit their practitioner after discharge. It must be assumed that they did not complete treatment. The average follow-up time of the remaining 39 patients was 159 weeks. In 13 cases the treatment was prolonged without obvious reason. For four patients who had not converted to a negative sputum culture at discharge, negativity was never been proven thereafter. Objective means of assessing patient compliance by H-urine strip testing were undertaken only in three cases. X-ray controls were performed adequately in 44.4% of the cases. By contrast monthly checks of liver enzymes had been done only in 23.1% of the patients.

We conclude that even a highly standardized protocol of short-course tuberculosis treatment requires a certain level of experience and compliance on the part of the practitioner. We accordingly recommend that every case of pulmonary tuberculosis should be reviewed at least twice by a chest physician.