YMXM motifs and signaling by an insulin receptor substrate 1 molecule without tyrosine phosphorylation sites

Tyrosine phosphorylation of insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1) by the activated receptors for insulin, IGF-1, and various cytokines creates binding sites for signaling proteins with Src homology 2 domains (SH2 proteins). Determining the role of specific SH2 proteins during insulin signaling has been difficult because IRS-1 possesses as many as 18 potential tyrosine phosphorylation sites, several of which contain redundant motifs. Using 32D cells, which contain no endogenous IRS proteins, we compared the signaling ability of an IRS-1 molecule in which 18 potential tyrosine phosphorylation sites were replaced by phenylalanine (IRS-1(F18)) with two derivative molecules which retained three YMXM motifs (IRS-1(3YMXM)) or the two COOH-terminal SHP2-Fyn binding sites (IRS-1(YCT)). During insulin stimulation, IRS-1(F18) failed to undergo tyrosine phosphorylation or mediate activation of the phosphotidylinositol (PI) 3'-kinase or p70(s6k); IRS-1(YCT) was tyrosine phosphorylated but also failed to mediate these signaling events. Neither IRS-1(3YMXM) nor IRS-1(YCT) mediated activation of mitogen-activated protein kinases. IRS-1(F18) and IRS-1(YCT) partially mediated similar levels of insulin-stimulated mitogenesis at high insulin concentrations, however, suggesting that IRS-1 contains phosphotyrosine-independent elements which effect mitogenic signals, and that the sites in IRS-l(YCT) do not augment this signal. IRS-1(3YMXM) mediated the maximal mitogenic response to insulin, although the response to insulin was more sensitive with wild-type IRS-1. By contrast, the association of IRS-1(3YMXM) with PI 3'-kinase was more sensitive to insulin than the association with IRS-1. Thus, the binding of SH2 proteins (such as PI 3'-kinase) by YMXM motifs in IRS-1 is an important element in the mitogenic response, but other elements are essential for full mitogenic sensitivity.